Menu of Plaza Pizza in Staten Island, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Plaza Pizza, nestled in the heart of Staten Island at 50 New Dorp Plaza, offers a genuine New York pizzeria experience that stands out in the borough. Their menu is a testament to both classic and inventive Italian-American fare, making it a local favorite. What truly defines Plaza Pizza is its commitment to quality and tradition, evident in every dish.

The Barbecue Chicken Pizza is a highlight, boasting a perfect balance of tangy barbecue sauce with tender grilled chicken, all layered on a thin, crispy crust. This pie delivers a smoky richness that lingers without overwhelming the palate. Equally enticing are the Mozzarella Sticks, crispy on the outside with a warm, gooey center, making for an irresistible appetizer or snack.

Another standout is the uniquely named Pepperoni Before It Needs the Oven Pie, a clever nod to their expertly prepared pepperoni slices, which are neither undercooked nor overdone, but achieve the perfect crispness that pizza lovers crave. The Fried Calamari here is fresh and tender, lightly breaded, accompanied by a zesty marinara that complements its natural sweetness.

Plaza Pizza doesn’t stop with traditional pizza alone. Their selection of Calzones and Rolls—from the savory Stromboli to the rich Eggplant Roll and the distinctive Broccoli RABE Roll—showcases a thoughtful layering of flavors and textures. The Family Sized Calzone is perfect for gatherings, offering a hearty, satisfying meal. For something lighter, the Garlic Knots deliver a perfect garlic-butter punch with a soft yet chewy bite.

Seasonal specials such as the Super Bowl Deals demonstrate Plaza Pizza's dedication to community and convenience. Combinations like 2 pies with 12 wings plus 2 liters of soda offer excellent value for a hearty game day feast.

Customer testimonials reflect the consistent satisfaction Plaza Pizza delivers. Longtime patrons like Michael DeFillippo praise the authentic cooking by Dennis, emphasizing the quality and rooted traditions. Sidney Mansueto hails their classic New York slice as the best in Staten Island, a sentiment echoed by many who crave an honest, thin crust with balanced sauce and mozzarella. Even the simplest offerings, like a plain cheese slice, impress with their crispness and straightforward flavor.

In sum, Plaza Pizza is more than a neighborhood spot; it’s a culinary landmark that balances traditional New York pizza craftsmanship with a diverse menu of Italian-American classics. Whether you’re drawn by the smoky BBQ chicken pie, the crispy mozzarella sticks, or an assortment of well-crafted rolls and calzones, this pizzeria consistently delivers comforting, flavorful dishes that resonate deeply with loyal customers and first-time visitors alike.